Asking the FTC to approve facial age estimation for verifiable parental consent

profile picture Sofi Summers 3 min read
Father and son using devices together

Together with the Privacy Certified program of the Entertainment Software Rating Board (ESRB) and Kids Web Services Ltd, a wholly owned Epic Games subsidiary, we are asking the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) for approval to implement facial age estimation as an authorised method for verifiable parental consent (VPC). The Children’s Online Privacy Protection Act (COPPA) requires companies to ensure they are not collecting personal data from children under the age of 13 without a parent’s consent. Currently, the COPPA Rule enumerates seven, non-exhaustive methods that enable parents to verify their consent. These include verification by government ID, credit card transaction, and a method that involves facial recognition, which is different from what we propose in our application.

We’d like the FTC to authorise facial age estimation as another VPC method to give parents and operators more choice in how parents can prove their age and grant consent. We are not seeking approval to implement this technology to check if children are old enough to purchase, download, and/or play a video game. Children are not involved in the age estimation process at all, which is designed to confirm that parents are adults, as required under COPPA.

We’d like to explain how the FTC application seeks to implement the technology in a way that is consistent with COPPA’s requirements for data minimisation, confidentiality and security.

  • Facial age estimation provides an accurate, reliable, accessible, fast, simple and privacy-preserving method to ensure that the person providing consent is an adult.
  • Facial age estimation is not facial recognition; it estimates a parent’s age without identifying them. It does so by converting the pixels of a facial image into numbers and comparing the pattern of numbers to patterns associated with known ages.
  • Facial age estimation does not create a database of faces. It doesn’t learn the user’s name, identity or anything about them. It does not scan their face against a database.
  • The technology is inclusive; it requires no collection of identity or payment card information.
  • It is accurate and does not show material bias among people of different skin tones. We have done extensive testing based on millions of facial scans and publish the accuracy levels transparently.
  • In our proposed application, facial age estimation is always presented as an option to parents alongside other approved methods of verification, providing the parent with a choice of methods.

If you have any questions about our FTC application, please get in touch.

Keep reading

A woman holding her mobile devise to her face to scan her biometrics.

How facial biometric verification protects your customers from identity fraud

Back in the day, identity theft mostly involved fraudsters stealing personal information, such as credit card details, to commit fraud or impersonate others in person. It was a pretty straightforward game of cat and mouse between fraudsters and a business, typically carried out face-to-face. As the world has become more digitised, identity fraud has evolved to meet this digital world. One powerful solution in our arsenal against identity fraud is biometric verification. Let’s dive into what it is, how it works, and why it’s crucial for keeping your customers and online community safe.   What is identity fraud? Identity

7 min read
Yoti's Facial Age Estimation results versus the NIST Age Estimation evaluation report

Why do Yoti facial age estimation results published by NIST differ to those reported by Yoti in its white papers

In September 2023, we submitted our facial age estimation model to the US National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST), as part of a public testing process. This is the first time since 2014 that NIST has evaluated facial age estimation algorithms. NIST age estimation reports are likely to become a globally trusted performance guide for vendor models. NIST assessed vendor Facial Age Estimation models using 4 data test sets at certain image sizes: NIST provides some example images: NIST note in their report that age estimation accuracy “will depend on

4 min read

Yoti assessed in the NIST Face Analysis Technology Evaluation program

An increasing amount of legislation is being introduced globally demanding that organisations effectively check the age of their users. It’s important that these age checks are inclusive; people should have a choice in how they prove their age. Regulators are recognising that not everyone will feel comfortable or be able to use a method based on identity documents. Facial age estimation gives people a way to prove their age without sharing their name, date of birth and other personal information from identity documents. It can improve online safety and help companies to comply with legislation, without having to process or

3 min read